Choose your deliciously different cheddar

Learn what makes each of our cheddars unique, what’s best to pair with your favorites, and why people love each and every one of them so much.

Extra Sharp Cheddar

Sharp Cheddar

Aged Reserve

Vermont White

Snacking

All Products

Extra Sharp Cheddar

Extra Sharp Cheddar
Tangy, smooth,
and slightly sweet
Hero Products Pairs Well
Pairs Well With:
Dark Chocolate, Cranberry & Apricot Preserves
See more pairings >

United States Championship Cheese
Contest® - Medalist 2013

Hero Product Award
“Cracker Barrel cheese is the best cheese I have ever tried so far!! I love the Extra Sharp Cheddar!! – Lisa T.
More Testimonials >

Our Varieties

  • Products Block Extra Sharp

    Extra Sharp Cheddar

  • Products Block Extra Sharp 2%

    Extra Sharp Cheddar Made with 2% Milk

  • Products Block Extra Sharp White

    Extra Sharp White
    Cheddar

  • Products Block Extra Sharp White 2%

    Extra Sharp White
    Cheddar Made with 2% Milk

  • Products Cheese Cuts Extra Sharp

    Extra Sharp Cheddar
    Cheese Cuts

  • Products Snack Extra Sharp 2%

    Extra Sharp Cheddar
    Cheese Bars Made with 2% Milk

  • Products Snack Extra Sharp White

    Extra Sharp White
    Cheddar Cheese Bars

  • Products Cuts Extrasharpreduced

    Extra Sharp Reduced Fat
    Cheddar Cheese Cuts Made with 2% Milk

Sharp Cheddar

Sharp Cheddar
Creamy and mildly fruity
with a buttery finish
Hero Products Pairs Well
Pairs Well With:
Pineapples, Pistachios & Honey
See More Pairings >

United States Championship Cheese
Contest® - Gold Medalist 2013

Hero Product Award
“Super sharp and apple
pie...mmmmmmm” – Tami B.
More Testimonials >

Our Varieties

  • Products Block Sharp

    Sharp Cheddar

  • Products Block Marbled Sharp

    Marbled Sharp Cheddar

  • Products Block Sharp White

    Sharp White
    Cheddar

  • Products Cuts Sharp White

    Sharp White Cheddar
    Cheese Cuts

  • Products Snack Sharp

    Sharp Cheddar
    Cheese Bars

Aged Reserve

Aged Reserve
Luscious, complex and full of flavor with a hint of earthy nuttiness
Hero Products Pairs Well
Pairs Well With:
Roasted Red Peppers, Salami
& Course Ground Mustard
See More Pairings >

world championship
cheese contest® - gold medalist 2012

Hero Product Award
“I won’t buy any other cheddar cheese. Aged reserve is my favorite. <3” – Victoria B.
More Testimonials>

Our Varieties

  • Products Block Aged

    Aged Reserve

Vermont White

Vermont White
Bold flavor with a firm texture
and complex cheddar character
Hero Products Pairs Well
Pairs Well With:
Strawberries, Basil, White
Chocolate and Balsamic Glaze
See More Pairings>
“Love your Vermont Sharp White Cheddar! Have it every holiday and special occasion! ” – Lynn K.
More Testimonials >

Our Varieties

  • Products Block Vermont 2%

    Vermont Sharp White
    Cheddar Made with 2% Milk

  • Products Block Vermont

    Vermont Sharp White
    Cheddar

Snacking

Vermont White
Make snack time
a moment to savor
Cracker Cuts:
Pre-sliced and perfectly sized for a cracker. Makes snacking and entertaining delicious and easy!
View varieties below
Snacking Bars:
Individually wrapped so that you can enjoy your favorite cheese on the go!
View varieties below
“Wow I never knew what I was missing, JALAPENO CHEDDAR CHEESE BARS!!!!!! The best.” – Mike R.
More Testimonials >

Our Varieties

  • Products Cuts Extra Sharp

    Extra Sharp Cheddar
    Cheese Cuts

  • Products Cuts Sharp White

    Sharp White Cheddar
    Cheese Cuts

  • Products Cuts Jalapeño

    Jalapeño Cheddar
    Cheese Cuts

  • Products Cuts Extra Sharp Reduced Fat

    Extra Sharp Reduced Fat
    Cheddar Cheese Cuts Made with 2% Milk

  • Products Snack Extra Sharp

    Extra Sharp Cheddar
    Cheese Bars Made with 2% Milk

  • Products Snack Extra Sharp White

    Extra Sharp White
    Cheddar Cheese Bars

  • Products Snack Jalapeño

    Jalapeño Cheddar
    Cheese Bars

  • Products Snack Sharp

    Sharp Cheddar
    Cheese Bars

All Products

Blocks

  • Products Block Aged

    Aged Reserve

    World Champ

    World Championship Cheese Contest®
    Gold Medalist 2012

  • Products Block Extra Sharp

    Extra Sharp Cheddar

    World Champ

    US Championship
    Cheese Contest®
    Medalist 2013

  • Products Block Extra Sharp White

    Extra Sharp White Cheddar

    World Champ

    US Championship
    Cheese Contest®
    Medalist 2013

  • Products Block Extra Sharp 2%

    Extra Sharp Cheddar Made with 2% Milk

    World Champ

    American Cheese
    Society Contest®
    Winner 2012

  • Products Block Extra Sharp White 2%

    Extra Sharp White Cheddar Made with 2% Milk

  • Products Block Sharp

    Sharp Cheddar

    World Champ

    US Championship
    Cheese Contest®
    Medalist 2013

  • Products Block Sharp White

    Sharp White Cheddar

    World Champ

    US Championship
    Cheese Contest®
    Medalist 2013

  • Products Block Vermont

    Vermont Sharp White
    Cheddar

  • Products Block Vermont 2%

    Vermont Sharp White
    Cheddar Made with 2% Milk

  • Products Block Jalape˜o

    Jalapeño

  • Products Block Mediterranean Herb

    Mediterranean Herb

  • Products Block Cracked Black Pepper

    Cracked Black Pepper

    World Champ

    World Championship Cheese Contest®
    Gold Medalist 2012

  • Products Block Marbled Sharp Cheddar

    Marbled Sharp Cheddar

  • Products Block Baby Swiss

    Baby Swiss

Cracker Cuts

  • Products Cuts Extra Sharp

    Extra Sharp Cheddar
    Cheese Cuts

  • Products Cuts Sharp White

    Sharp White Cheddar
    Cheese Cuts

  • Products Cuts Jalapeño

    Jalapeño Cheddar
    Cheese Cuts

  • Products Cuts Extra Sharp Reduced Fat

    Extra Sharp Reduced Fat
    Cheddar Cheese Cuts Made with 2% Milk

Snacking Bars

  • Products Snack Extra Sharp

    Extra Sharp Cheddar
    Cheese Bars Made with 2% Milk

  • Products Snack Extra Sharp White

    Extra Sharp White
    Cheddar Cheese Bars

  • Products Snack Jalapeño

    Jalapeño Cheddar
    Cheese Bars

  • Products Snack Sharp

    Sharp Cheddar
    Cheese Bars